Sunday, 23 December 2012

2012 in review: The moans and groans


2012 has been another busy year for cricket with a lot of positives to look back on. But in this particular article I’ll look at some of the things which have got steam coming out of my ears over the past twelve months. There is only one place to start:

1. The weather

2012 was an absolutely shocking year weather-wise. Club cricketers, county cricketers and international cricketers spent most of the English summer watching weather forecasts and huddled inside pavilions. Whole rounds of Championship matches were virtually wiped out and, as a result, Yorkshire were promoted after drawing eleven matches. Edgbaston was underwater every time they tried to play an international. The club season was even worse hit. My local league surpassed the previous record for matches called off in a season before the half-way point had even been reached. Quite simply the rain wreaked havoc during the English season.

2. The schedule for England v South Africa

It was one of the most eagerly anticipated non-Ashes Test series for years but a combination of England’s performance, the Olympics and the schedule combined to make it a peripheral event in the 2012 experiences of most sports fans.  Whilst the ECB could do very little to change matters on the field, the schedule left a lot to be desired. For a start there were only three matches, making a mockery of the designation of matches between the two sides as an ‘icon’ series to be contested over five. In addition, the 2nd Test at Headingley clashed directly with the most important sports event to hit British shores, ever. Even my eyes were elsewhere when Kevin Pietersen was producing one of his masterclasses. Finally, the two Tests either side of the Olympics were both held in London. Although good crowds turned up, it seemed odd to give the two most lucrative cricket matches of the year to a city who’s sports fans could not complain of a shortage of world class competition. The 30 seconds cricket got on Sports Personality of the Year showed how much this series had been marginalised. That could easily have been avoided with more sensible scheduling.

3. The BCCI’s stance on photographers

As somebody who’s Dad was a professional golf photographer, and campaigned extensively on behalf of photographers in all sports, it saddened me to see the BCCI withold accreditation from major photographic agencies and insist that the only published pictures came from their website.  The British press deserve a pat on the back for deciding not to take the BCCI pictures. The BCCI’s stance sets a dangerous precedent for press freedom. But more than that it is a tremendous kick in the teeth to the specialist photographers, who havemade a career out of being amongst the best in their field. Given that the BCCI have no real interest in how good the pictures are, it can only be assumed that their photographers are those willing to work for the lowest salary and won’t take any pictures which paint the board in a bad light. The industry is already facing challenges in the 21st century environment, and it seems ridiculous that cricket’s administrators want to make life even harder for skilled professionals that deserve to make a living.

4.  The actions of the Sri Lankan board

Whilst the BCCI’s sins are well known, less attention has been paid to SLC. At the start of the year they couldn’t afford to pay their players. So they charged British fans extortionate prices to get into the Galle Test. Arguably fair enough. Then they hosted a World Twenty20, which should have brought in lots of cash. But they still felt the need to cancel or shorten Test series after Test series to make room for ODIs against India. This only gets worse next year, and is already starting to have an effect on other nations. West Indies had a thin schedule in the first place, but their series at home to Sri Lanka has now been cancelled to make way for guess what? An ODI tri-series involving India. Nobody would argue with Mahela Jayawardene when he says that he has “lost all confidence in dealing with SLC”.

5. Calls for a franchise system in England

Sorry if you’ve heard this one from me before - it’s a bit of a personal campaign of mine. This summer player after player, pundit after pundit, former player after former player, came out to pledge their support for an IPL or Big Bash-style franchise system in the UK. The justification was that it would spice up the competition, bring the crowds back and attract global stars. But every single person that wanted a franchise system was missing the point. In the long-run its unrealistic for domestic cricket in England to fill big grounds whoever’s playing and wherever its played. Franchises would surely be given to the big cities, robbing those grounds which actually do well out of Twenty20 of their main income stream. Meanwhile, its assumed that Yorkshire fans will suddenly want to support the Leeds franchise in the new T20, and that those who pour in for T20 at Chelmsford will head to The Oval. At the end of the day franchises can’t do anything about the rain either…


No comments:

Post a Comment